Third Graders, Please do a close read of the article Muhammad Ali: The Greatest. Think about what makes Muhammad Ali such an important role model. Then, discuss these things using the routine below. Make a claim about Muhammad Ali. Use the article to support your claim with evidence. Make sure to state where you got your information from!! Then, explain another person who you can think of that is a role model to you! Comment on 2 or more friends ideas with a question, connection, or praise.
103 Comments
Joel
2/12/2016 11:39:05 am
Claim - Mohaamad Ali is famous.
Reply
Angela
2/12/2016 11:44:46 am
That`s what I mostly said!
Reply
Ani
2/12/2016 11:45:19 am
I respecfully agree but in the other hand I think he was famous for freedom.
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 11:47:41 am
What do you mean, Ani?
Iris
2/12/2016 11:54:15 am
What..what did you mean?
Benjamin
2/12/2016 12:01:52 pm
Me too!👍
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 11:47:13 am
How do you know this, Joel? Where did you get your evidence? Also, who is a hero to you?
Reply
Ani
2/12/2016 11:50:08 am
I mean that he told the amaricans not to fight back
Rylieokulich
2/12/2016 11:57:00 am
Ani I think that your Claim was your Resoning because you exsplained what it was about. But also How did mohamd tell amercans to urge and mulims. I Dont really understand what you mean?
Manish
2/12/2016 11:49:18 am
Add more please explain your thinking and that evidense isnt good enough
Reply
Jessica
2/12/2016 11:50:45 am
Maybe you could think deeper.
Reply
Rylie Okulich
2/12/2016 11:51:27 am
What else was he famous for and what is your Resoning?
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 12:06:24 pm
Good comments, Rylie!
SOFIA
2/12/2016 11:51:55 am
Why do you tyhink that he is such a famis guy? Give me and the class more about what you have learned.
Reply
Abdul
2/12/2016 11:53:08 am
I wrote the same thing as you
Reply
ashwika
2/12/2016 11:58:39 am
But what is your reasoning
Reply
Neha
2/12/2016 12:02:52 pm
What is your reasoning Joel.
Reply
Ani
2/12/2016 11:40:33 am
Claim I think mohamad ali is a great role moddel i think that because in the text it said that he told the amaricans to urged to not look at muslims as bad people and use peace.
Reply
Joel
2/12/2016 11:44:39 am
I am also admired by MLK.
Reply
Angela
2/12/2016 11:45:46 am
WOW!
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 11:48:32 am
Ani, I also connected Muhammad Ali to Martin Luther King, Jr! I admire them both for all of their heroic acts of kindness for the world.
Reply
Iris
2/12/2016 11:50:52 am
That's what I said!
Hadi
2/12/2016 11:57:33 am
Oh yeah..... I forgot i should have wrote MLKJ my second role model☹️
Reply
Victoria
2/12/2016 12:00:28 pm
What do you mean by rolemodle
Ani
2/12/2016 12:00:17 pm
He merged and told the amaricans not to fight back
Reply
Ani
2/12/2016 11:42:59 am
I also know that mohamad Ali is brother turned to muslim. I also know he started boxing when he was 12.
Reply
Joel
2/12/2016 11:47:41 am
That is some great background knowledge
Reply
Neha
2/12/2016 12:00:40 pm
But did he like boxing
Reply
Ani
2/12/2016 12:07:27 pm
Yes it was his leagcy! I know this because i read who is mohamad Ali
Angela
2/12/2016 11:43:23 am
CLAIM:
Reply
Raegan
2/12/2016 11:47:31 am
He was not just faoumes of boxing also his words
Reply
Iris
2/12/2016 11:50:19 am
And his courage!
Abdul
2/12/2016 11:54:57 am
I agree Raegen.
Ankita
2/12/2016 12:12:14 pm
Me too i agree.
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 11:49:57 am
Do you think that means he is one of the most famous people or just the most famous boxer?
Reply
Ankita
2/12/2016 12:09:08 pm
He is both right?
Hadi
2/14/2016 11:37:08 am
Angela i think you can add more details about the evidence
Reply
Raegan
2/12/2016 11:44:52 am
I think mudammad ali was a great person
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 11:50:36 am
Yes I think he was a great person, too! Where did you get your evidence?
Reply
Rylie Okulich
2/12/2016 11:58:21 am
Wow thats alot of knolage! great Thinking
Reply
Hadi
2/14/2016 11:38:36 am
I agree raegan i also think that he was a great person 👍
Reply
Jathan
2/12/2016 11:46:13 am
CLAIM: Muhammad should not only be called the greatest, he is the greatest.
Reply
Jathan
2/12/2016 11:51:15 am
For my claim, M.A. Is one of the greatest. SORRY!
Reply
Jessica
2/12/2016 11:52:45 am
What?
Reply
Jathan
2/12/2016 11:55:46 am
Did I say something wrong Jessica:(
Manish
2/12/2016 11:52:52 am
Thats what I said but you wrote more
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 11:54:22 am
I agree that he is pretty great! He is courageous and a hero, too. Very interesting facts about Albert Einstein. How do you know all this I wonder?
Reply
Jathan
2/12/2016 12:03:27 pm
Go on the website www.Basher.com. Then look at buy books then look for superstars of science (not superstars of history). Basher books are really fun and really helpful too. Superstars of history does tell about Albert Einstein but I don't think it's about the bombs. The superstars of history is in the troy public library but superstars of science, you should ask one of the workers there to look for an other library to give you. A couple days later you can look for the book you ordered and BAM!! You got the fun, awesome book.(there are other scientists there too) but I have the book so if you want me to bring it in...
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 12:09:22 pm
That would be great, Jathan!
Nidhi
2/12/2016 12:01:07 pm
I agree with you Jathan!I agree because Albert Enstien did things that go to how great Muhammand Ali.I also agree that Muhammand Ali is not just called great,he is the greatest.Good Job and Great evidence with what you said.I agree.
Reply
Hadi
2/14/2016 11:39:49 am
OMG!!! Jathan i really liked !!! Your claim,evidence and reasoning
Reply
Manish
2/12/2016 11:47:51 am
In the article Muhamid ali is is famouse because of his way of speaking and his courage he was a hero . So my evidense is that he got a disease but he put all of that behind him and urged America not to look down at musilums. My dad is my hero because I look up to him and want to be like him one fine day.
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 11:56:06 am
He definitely is courageous! Aw your dad is pretty great, too! I agree.
Reply
Jessica
2/12/2016 11:48:19 am
Never giving up. He got a dezess. But muhammad all dident give up.It is in paragrath 3.
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 11:56:59 am
Make sure you write in complete sentences and explain who you are talking about!
Reply
Iris
2/12/2016 11:48:57 am
Muhammed Ali was is an important rolmodel becase in the article,it said that he was kown mainly for his courage and his way of speaking and his disire to help others.
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 11:59:13 am
What was he courageous about? I noticed your hero and Ani's hero are the same!
Reply
Rylie okulich
2/12/2016 11:49:03 am
Claim: My Claim is that Muamid ali was one of the greatest boxers and always has corage.
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 12:00:39 pm
Great evidence to support your claim. Where did you get this information from?
Reply
Sofia
2/12/2016 12:02:11 pm
I think that those two people are great people to look up to.
Reply
Hadi
2/14/2016 11:44:15 am
Good job Rylie i really like what you wrote.
Reply
Abdul
2/12/2016 11:49:12 am
CLAIM: Ali became one of the most famous people.
Reply
Kyla
2/12/2016 11:52:37 am
GOOD claim i liked it becuse ali did become a famous person
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 12:03:01 pm
Me too!
Iris
2/12/2016 11:52:58 am
Who could you connect him to,how are they alike?
Reply
Ashwika
2/12/2016 11:57:08 am
Is threre another person thats couraging
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 12:07:14 pm
Hi Abdul, How was he courageous and what did he speak about to make him famous? I think you need to support your claim a bit more!!
Reply
Kyla
2/12/2016 11:49:36 am
Mouhamad ali was born in louisvill kuntucky in 1942.he got a gold medal in boxing. He changed his name from clay to mouhamad ali.today he is sufering from parkinksons dezeiz it afects his brain. In 2005 he got a pressedents meadel of freedom from making a speach and he liked to make speeches too
Reply
Iris
2/12/2016 11:58:27 am
For your evidence,what did you get from the article,I don't clearly know
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 12:02:39 pm
I agree, Iris. Good comment!
Sofia
2/12/2016 11:49:45 am
I camn make a claim about ali and that claim is that he is a very strong man and he tought me that i can dio anything I can do.In the article the author who rote it said ''ali sufers from a desaes called parkinsens desaes in wich efects his brain and his ability to speak and move his body. This made me think that he was a very amazing guy to have won an award for boxing with such an ability to have a deseas and still win such an honarable award. In the year of 1942 clay joined the muslim faith. He also changed his name from CASSIOUS CLAY to MUHAMMAD ALI.
Reply
Sofia
2/12/2016 11:56:39 am
My hero is quen stifani because i like music and i am also a huge fan of all her CD'S. My favoite song by her isHARISHUCO GIRL. She inspiers me for my music because she makes songs from different religons.
Reply
Ms.Battaglia
2/12/2016 12:05:43 pm
He is a strong man....great claim. What a great thought and reflection, Sofia. Is there someone else that is a hero to you?
Reply
Nidhi
2/12/2016 12:06:19 pm
If i knew who Queen S. was i woulld totally agree with you.
Reply
Hadi
2/14/2016 11:47:47 am
Why did she make songs for diffrent religons ?🤔
Reply
2/12/2016 11:50:58 am
I think Muhamd Ali has a lot of faith because in the article they told us that he was suffering from a dis-ability but still did not lose faith and told evreyone the attacks did not matter.
Reply
ashwika
2/12/2016 11:59:02 am
Whats your reasoning Arjun?
Reply
Hadi
2/12/2016 11:53:23 am
The artical is muhammed ali he is the best boxer of all time. How i know is by watching all of his fights and reading books about him. Finnaly my role model is cristiono rolando
Reply
JOEL
2/12/2016 11:53:29 am
I got my evidence from the article
Reply
ASHWIKA
2/12/2016 11:54:06 am
Claim:MA was a famous boxer in the world
Reply
Victoria
2/12/2016 12:04:09 pm
Reply
Victoria
2/12/2016 11:56:32 am
I thinkn mudammad ali is a strong guy becuase he won the frist world heavyweight title he got that by the summer olympics he won the boxing medal. I got this imformation in mudamma ali the great. Mudammad ali is famus becuase he won the medal that i said and becuase he gave speechs that said not lookdown on your self. My hero is my family becuase they love me and i love them too. I love they becuase they feed me and they gave me stuff and becuase they gave me a room to my self.
Reply
Victoria
2/12/2016 12:01:46 pm
He is also the greatest boxer in the world/history
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 12:11:10 pm
He is a strong guy for so many reasons!
Reply
Nidhi
2/12/2016 11:56:44 am
Muhammand Ali is an important person because he hade a disease but he still didnt give up.My claim about Muhammand Ali is strong because he had a disease but he still didnt give up and he is a great boxer,he won the gold medal at the olympuics.I got all of my info from the article i read.Another role model is Martin Luther King Junior because he went to jail a couple times but he still didnt give up,the white people were really mean but he still didnt give up and when he died everyone still follows him
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 12:10:14 pm
I agree that he didn't give up and he's strong. Where did you get this information from? Which article?
Reply
TAIMUR
2/12/2016 11:56:53 am
Muhammad Ali was a great boxer. In fact he was the greatest boxer of all time. His name used to be Cassius Clay. He converted to Islam in 1975. He was born in 1942 and is 74 years old in the year 2016. He was so good people called him the Louiseville Lip and The peoples Champion. I have a question. Why did he start doing boxing anyways? Was it to put a awesome show show on for the crowd or to be a champion? Some other people heroes Martin Luther King Jr. And Malcomb Little or Malcom X.
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 12:12:20 pm
Cassius Clay, huh? I didn't know that! Where did you learn all this from? What information from this article do you have to support your claim.
Reply
Angelina
2/12/2016 11:57:52 am
Claim: muhammud ali is a leader
Reply
Angelina
2/12/2016 12:02:52 pm
Also i think martin luther king is a great leader because he let people that are white and black go together so i thinks thats a great way of leadership
Reply
Ms. Battaglia
2/12/2016 12:12:59 pm
Great job, Angelina!
Reply
Neha
2/12/2016 11:57:58 am
CLAIM; Muhammad Ali is a guy who never gives up.
Reply
Nidhi
2/12/2016 12:04:08 pm
I agree with you Akanksha! The part i agree with is that Muhammand Ali is famous because he had faith and courage because if Muhammand Ali didnt have faith and courage he wouldnt be as famous as he is right now.
Reply
Akanksha
2/12/2016 11:59:14 am
Claim: I think that Muhammand Ali is a person who is strong and wants to learn and be good at almost evreything.
Reply
Benjamin
2/12/2016 12:06:31 pm
I agree!
Reply
Benjamin
2/12/2016 11:59:35 am
Claim: Muhamaad Ali is very strong.
Reply
Angelina
2/12/2016 12:05:50 pm
Wht do you think your parents is a role model
Reply
Benjamin
2/12/2016 12:07:19 pm
Same reason as first one.
Benjamin
2/12/2016 12:08:10 pm
I meant the first role model.
Ankita
2/12/2016 12:01:52 pm
cassius clay is famous because his boxing. He is so good at boxing people called him " the greatest".
Reply
Ani
2/12/2016 12:06:05 pm
I dont really get it and what makes you say that
Reply
Richa
2/12/2016 12:04:32 pm
CLAIM
Reply
Ankita
2/12/2016 12:04:55 pm
P.s. Martin luther king and cassius clay also has good role models.
Reply
Leave a Reply. |
AuthorThis site is created and updated by students in Mrs. Marcinkoski's class. Archives
January 2018
Categories |